Old California Botanicals marmalade jars

Ways to use marmalade beyond toast

By JP Beall ·

A jar of marmalade is sugar, cooked citrus peel and pectin, and those three things do a lot of work in a kitchen. The sugar caramelizes into a glaze, the peel brings the bitterness and perfume of zest, and the pectin thickens a sauce as it reduces. So the jar can stand in for honey, brown sugar, orange juice and zest, often all at once.

Here is every way we've used it so far, sorted by meal. Each link goes to a full recipe.

Glazes for dinner

Salads and dressings

Pies, cakes and cookies

Breakfast

For a crowd

In a glass

Which marmalade for which job?

If you're making… Reach for Why
Savory glazes for wings, chicken and ham Navel Orange or Mandarin Navel is the classic California orange, with honey, warm spice and a bright, rounded finish. Mandarin is our most aromatic jar, floral and honeyed, and a natural with roasted pork.
Fish, dressings and cocktails Eureka Lemon or Meyer Lemon Eureka is clean lemon with low acidity, like a lemon drop, so it brightens without a sharp bite. Meyer is fuller and more herbal, with a mandarin note: the lemon marmalade for cooks.
Cheese boards and bitter-leaf salads Duncan or Melogold Grapefruit Duncan is bold and lightly tannic, balancing brightness and bitterness, so it stands up to rich cheese. Melogold is the gentler grapefruit, smooth with a blackberry note, for anyone who wants less bitterness.
Cookies, cakes and breakfast Mandarin, Minneola Tangelo or Valencia Orange Mandarin's honeyed, floral sweetness suits baking. Minneola starts bright and finishes darker, with hints of allspice and papaya, adding depth to scones, toast and tea. Valencia is our sweetest marmalade, lush and honeyed with a hint of mango, for pancakes, yogurt and croissants.

Three swaps to remember

  • For honey in a glaze: use about ¾ cup of marmalade where a recipe calls for about ½ cup of honey, chop any long shreds of peel, and simmer until it coats a spoon, as in our wings recipe.
  • For jam in cookies: our thumbprints and Linzer cookies use marmalade in place of jam. Chop the peel so it spreads evenly.
  • For sugar or syrup in a drink: dissolve the marmalade first, as in our whiskey sour.

How long will the jar last?

Our guide to whether marmalade goes bad covers how long a jar keeps, opened and unopened, and the signs that it has spoiled.

We'll keep adding recipes here through the holidays. Browse the marmalades.

More in Kitchen & Recipes

← Apple pie with marmalade Pumpkin pie with marmalade →

Latest from the Journal


Yellow citrus fruit on tree
Citrus & the Grove

Eureka vs Lisbon lemons, and how to tell the trees apart

By JP Beall

Eureka and Lisbon lemons are sold as one fruit because they nearly are one fruit. The trees are a different matter: one is thornless and...

Read more
Oranges ripening on a tree under a clear blue sky
Citrus & the Grove

California citrus season, month by month

By JP Beall

Citrus is ripe somewhere in California every month of the year. This guide sets out which oranges, mandarins, lemons, limes and grapefruit are in season...

Read more