Around 1830, a grapefruit seedling went into the ground near Safety Harbor, Florida. That tree is the parent of the Duncan grapefruit, which UC Riverside's collection describes as likely the longest-cultivated grapefruit variety in the US. Duncan is large, pale-fleshed and full of seeds, and its flavor was the Florida standard for decades.
Where did the Duncan grapefruit come from?
The seed came from Florida's first grapefruit planting, made by Count Odette Phillippe, who is credited with bringing the fruit over from the West Indies. For about sixty years the resulting tree had no variety name at all. It was finally named and introduced around 1892, after A. L. Duncan of nearby Dunedin, the man who put it on the market.
The UC Riverside Citrus Variety Collection carries the account from The Citrus Industry, a 1967 reference work. Because grapefruit seeds are highly polyembryonic, most seedlings come true to the mother tree. Many early Florida "varieties" were therefore probably Duncan under other names, and several were marketed as Duncan anyway. One of them, a tree called Bowen used in early Florida breeding work, turned out in 1962 to be Duncan all along.
What sets a Duncan grapefruit apart
Seeds, first of all, and plenty of them. UF/IFAS, in its guide Citrus Culture in the Home Landscape, gives 30 to 70 seeds in a Duncan against 0 to 6 in every modern grapefruit it names, Marsh and Star Ruby among them.
The fruit is almost round, with a smooth, light yellow rind of medium thickness and very pale, buff-colored flesh. In a 2009 tasting, the collection's staff summed up the flavor as "rich, fruity, intense, less bitter."
The 1967 description calls the flavor "pronounced and excellent", and adds that the tree may be the most cold-resistant of the grapefruit.
In Florida, Duncan's season runs from December to May, and at Riverside from January to May. Like every grapefruit, it needs a lot of summer heat to taste its best.
Why did seedless grapefruit win?
The Marsh grapefruit decided it. Marsh turned up as a chance seedling near Lakeland around 1860, and once a nurseryman recognized in 1886 that it was nearly seedless, it spread fast. By 1967 it was, in UC Riverside's words, "by far the leading variety" worldwide, and the pink and red varieties that mattered most commercially at that time traced back to it.
Duncan kept its reputation and lost the fresh market. In 1967 it was still Florida's benchmark for grapefruit flavor, even though seedless varieties had "largely displaced it" in fresh fruit. Processing revived some interest, since it canned better, and Duncan still made up about 7 percent of the grapefruit planted in Florida between 1956 and 1966.
In California, Duncan is now a grower's rarity. The 2026 California Citrus Acreage Report names six grapefruit varieties, from Star Ruby at 3,286 acres down to Marsh at 253, and folds anything under 50 acres into "All Other Varieties." Duncan isn't named, so the state's Duncan trees, including those that supply the California-grown fruit in our jar, add up to less than that cutoff.
Why a seedy grapefruit suits marmalade
The seeds that cost Duncan its place in the fruit bowl are useful in a preserving pan. Citrus pith and membranes carry pectin, and so do the seeds, and cooks who make cut-rind marmalade often tie them into a cheesecloth bag to simmer with the fruit. Marisa McClellan of Food in Jars describes doing exactly that in her marmalade guide, and notes that fruit such as blood oranges and Cara Caras is often seed-free, with only a thin layer of pith. For those she keeps a stash of frozen lemon seeds to help the set.
A Duncan brings its own supply, plus the medium-thick rind that gives a marmalade its peel. Then there's flavor. The 1967 text judges seedless Marsh good in flavor but milder than some of the seeded kinds, and in a jar that intensity is the whole point.
The Duncan Grapefruit Marmalade we make sits at the bitter end of our range, with gentle tannin, bright peel and a surprising maraschino cherry finish. Its label lists no added pectin, so the set comes from the fruit itself. That bitterness works against bourbon in a sour, with proportions on our marmalade cocktails page.
Duncan's best-known offspring
Most people who have eaten a Minneola have eaten half a Duncan. The Minneola tangelo is a cross of Duncan and the Dancy mandarin that the USDA put out in 1931, and it sometimes goes by Honeybell. Our Minneola Tangelo Marmalade has a darker, lingering finish that may owe something to that grapefruit parent. Other tangelos and hybrids grown in the state have their own post on California specialty citrus.
Growing a Duncan at home
For a backyard tree, the seeds matter less than the flavor. The UF/IFAS guide calls Duncan "one of the best for home use, its quality compensating for its seediness." If a garden center doesn't stock one, a specialty citrus nursery may be able to order it. Wherever it comes from, give the tree the hottest spot you have: UC Riverside notes that grapefruit must be grown where its high heat requirement can be met.
Photo by Anna Wlodarczyk on Unsplash.